Restrictive covenants, such as those which seek to prevent solicitation of customers, clients, suppliers, other employees, or general competition for a defined period after termination, are standard in mid- to high-level employment contracts.

The general rule in English law, which has been adopted into Bermuda law by Supreme Court and Court of Appeal precedent, is that any contractual term which purports to restrict an employee’s trade activities after termination of their employment is contrary to public policy and void as a restraint of trade; except to the extent that the employer can show:

The term is designed to protect a legitimate proprietary interest of the employer, which:

a. may include the employer’s trade connections with customers and suppliers, confidential information or trade secrets;

b. does not extend to preventing competition by the use of the employee’s skills and expertise;

The restriction is designed to provide only such protection as is reasonable having regard to:

a. the interests of the parties, being the employer’s proprietary interest and the employee’s interest in participating in his trade; and

b. the public’s interest, being the interest of the public in having appropriately skilled and experienced personnel participate in the trade.

In the ordinary course, a restrictive covenant which is designed to protect a legitimate proprietary interest but does so by way of unreasonable restrictions is void. The court will not rewrite a covenant which is wider than reasonably necessary. For instance, if a three year period specified in a covenant is considered to be too wide but a one period would be appropriate in the circumstances of the case, the covenant will still fail. For this reason, it is also important to ensure that restrictive covenants are expressed to severable both from each other (if there is more than one) and from the rest of the contract of employment.

As such employers should take great care, and seek legal advice in each case, to ensure that any restrictive covenants provide reasonable protection necessary to protect the legitimate proprietary interest of the employer but go no wider, otherwise such covenants will be at risk of being held to be unenforceable. What might be considered a reasonable scope for a restrictive covenant will vary in each case, across different industry sectors and with the seniority of the employee concerned. It is therefore important to review whether covenants are sufficiently robust as an employee progresses up the promotion ladder, and also to consider, as part of reasonableness, the cumulative effects of a restrictive covenant together with other related contractual clauses such as garden leave provisions.

In the event of an actual or threatened breach of a restrictive covenant, whether by an individual employee or by a team (a ‘springboard’ action), the covenant can be enforced by an application for an injunction, often on a without notice basis, and often coupled with applications for disclosure, damages (if appropriate), disgorgement of profits and restraints on use of the employer’s confidential information.

Share
X.com LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
Website-Code-Bermuda
13 Dec 2024

Gifting a home in Bermuda: a review of your options

A home can be gifted to a spouse, or the next generation either during an owner’s life, or as an i...

050-Insolvency-Restructuring-Grid-Image
10 Dec 2024

Bermuda: Americas Restructuring Review 2025

This article discusses the defining features of Bermuda’s insolvency landscape and the primary ins...

Appleby-Website-Privacy-and-Data-Protection
5 Dec 2024

Digital identity services in Bermuda

There is steep demand for the ability to authenticate a person’s identity through the use of a tru...

Appleby-Website-Privacy-and-Data-Protection
28 Nov 2024

Augmented Advocacy Series (Bermuda): Copyright infringement in the age of AI

Artificial intelligence is revolutionising the way that humans solve problems and create.

Appleby-Website-Employment-and-Immigration
19 Nov 2024

When and how to vary a Bermuda contract of employment

A contract of employment is a legal agreement that sets out the terms and conditions of an employee�...

Technology and Innovation
8 Nov 2024

When non-tech companies buy IT

Generally, there are three categories of information technology buyers: non-technology enterprises, ...

050-Insolvency-Restructuring-Grid-Image
15 Oct 2024

Insolvency: Bermuda

In-Depth: Insolvency (formerly The Insolvency Review) offers an incisive review of the most conseque...

Appleby-Website-Insurance-and-Reinsurance
10 Oct 2024

Recovery planning for commercial insurers

New rules released by the Bermuda Monetary Authority aim to equip certain insurers with a structured...

The Global Website header
7 Oct 2024

The Global – your offshore corporate law questions answered: October 2024

The Global is a quarterly collection of corporate expert insights and analysis across Appleby's glob...